1 in 7 New York City Elementary Students Will Be Homeless, Report Says - NYTimes.com


Amelia Watts, of New York City’s Human Resources Administration, talking to parents outside of a Brooklyn school as part of a program aimed at preventing families from becoming homeless.  Sam Hodgson for The New York Times

There were 100,000 homeless students in New York City public schools during the 2015-16 school year, a number equal to the population of Albany.

The daunting challenges that creates, both for individual children struggling to learn and for schools trying to improve performance, are laid out in a report to be released on Wednesday by the Institute for Children, Poverty, and Homelessness. If current trends continue, the report’s authors say, one in every seven New York City public school students will be homeless at some point during elementary school.

“In every school classroom, that’s two or three kids,” said Anna Shaw-Amoah, principal policy analyst at the institute. “And the challenges are not just about whether you’re currently living in a shelter or a doubled up setting, but did they have that experience last year, or did they have this experience in kindergarten? The instability really travels with students. If you fall behind in one year, it’s going to be harder to get on grade level the next year.”

Within the last six years, more than 140,000 New York City students have been homeless, the report said.

The growing number of homeless children is part of the fallout of the city’s housing crisis, which has seen a growing number of families in city shelters, as rents have risen, federal and state aid has dwindled, and a state rental assistance program ended. The de Blasio administration has struggled to slow the rising numbers, but with little success.

Homelessness is difficult under any circumstances, but for children, the stress and physical dislocation can be like a tornado dropped into the school day. Students bounce from school to school as their family leaves home, perhaps staying with friends, before entering the shelter system, where they are often moved from place to place. Getting children to school each day becomes an enormous challenge, especially if families have recently moved across the city.

The typical homeless elementary school student missed 88 days of school, according to the report, which is almost half of a school year.

Families who have lost their home must make the wrenching choice of leaving a child in a school they know, or transferring them to a school closer to where they are staying. Moving to a new school may further the feeling of dislocation, but it makes it easier for the child to get to class. The report found that the typical homeless child transferred schools midyear at least two times during elementary school.

Homeless children were more likely than those with stable housing to be on the wrong side of a huge array of indicators. They were more likely to to be suspended or drop out, more likely to face delays in being identified as needing special education services, and more likely to need services to help them learn English. Their proficiency rates on the state math and English exams for third through eighth graders were about 20 points lower than classmates’. And homeless students graduated at a rate of just 55 percent, while students with stable housing graduated at a rate of 74 percent.

One in every six students identified as still learning English was classified as homeless, according to the report. Most of them were doubled up. Children learning English who were homeless were more likely to need services longer than their peers with a stable place to live.

The institute relied on the city’s data for its report. The definition used by the city for homelessness includes any child in “temporary housing” at some point during the school year. This can mean a student whose family is living in its car or in a motel, staying with extended family or friends, or living in shelters. The number of students in shelters during the 2015-16 school year was 33,000, according to the city’s Independent Budget Office.

“We recognize students in temporary housing face additional challenges and are providing more resources,” Toya Holness, a spokeswoman for the city’s education department, said in an email. She cited bus services for students in kindergarten through sixth grade who live in shelters, and said the city has hired more social workers in schools with large numbers of homeless students.

The city has also made a push to register more homeless students for pre-K, an effort the report found to be working — the institute found a 17 percent increase in pre-K enrollment among homeless children from the 2014-15 school year to the 2015-16 school year. More broadly, the de Blasio administration has announced a plan to open 90 new shelters to replace a makeshift network of hotels and temporary apartments scattered across the city and to try to allow families to stay closer to their home neighborhood and schools.

Another crucial point in the report is how homeless students are distributed among the city’s schools, with some schools and districts seeing intense concentrations, while others bear a relatively light burden. In Bayside, Queens, 823 students were homeless in the 2015-16 school year, while in District 10 in the Bronx, which includes neighborhoods like Fordham and Belmont, more than 10,000 students did not have a stable place to live.

Will limited-equity co-ops come back?

Tuesday, August 15, 2017
In This Issue: Taking Back the Front Porch ● Could Public Art Stifle Community Conversation? ● How to Build a Case for Community Development and Affordable Housing ● Will Limited-Equity Co-ops Come Back? ● Also: Resources ● You Said It! ● In Case You Missed It ● Jobs ● More
Joyce Fernandes, artist, writer, and cultural worker
There is an iconic image of a front porch that lives in the American imagination—one of shared conversation, observation, and peace. The front porch is in between our private family space and our more public-facing community spaces where we create our own definition of “community.” In many parts of Chicago, this space is often a battleground.

Let me explain this “battleground” with an example of a front porch located near my former office in Chicago. Every day I would walk by a brick apartment building with an open porch typically occupied by 3 or 4 young men, a pit bull, and occasionally an older woman. Even though I passed by hundreds of times, we never surpassed exchanges of brief, nearly indiscernible nods. About a year into this routine, I was walking with an artist colleague to a meeting around the corner, and for the first time, there was a verbal exchange . . .
Looking for a Job? Scroll Down...
Miriam Axel-Lute, Shelterforce
There will be important functions in public space that are not always “art,” whose value is not in proportion to their prettiness. I am reminded of the fights in New York City in the late 1990s to save community gardens on city land that were at risk of development. The ones that were saved were more likely to be the ones that looked more like a pretty garden, completely full of greenery and flowers in well-ordered beds. The ones that prominently featured a less spiffy looking gathering spot, perhaps with bare dirt and folding chairs, were harder to rally broad support for—even though they were serving a crucial function as a gathering place, often for elderly residents.

Places where things are posted, whether official bulletin boards or blank spots on the streets, are not always pretty, but . . .
Lillian M. Ortiz, Shelterforce
Limited-equity co-ops (LECs)—a form of cooperative housing intended to preserve affordability for low- and moderate-income households—aren’t built at the rate at which they were erected in the ’60s, ’70s, and ’80s when LECs were all the rage in San Francisco, New York, and Washington, D.C. In those days there were more financing options available, including subsidies and below-market interest rates, that allowed developers to secure affordable loans to build LECs.

While the total number of LECs across the nation has certainly dwindled, in recent years there has been what some might call the beginning of a resurgence across the country. What’s leading the renewed interest in this model of resident-controlled, long-term affordable housing?
Looking for a Job? Keep Scrolling...
Despite tremendous progress and success in our work, we still have not built strong enough political will at the national level to adequately respond to the country’s affordability and community development challenges regardless of which party is in the majority or in the White House. If we are not careful, this could lead to a segmented, narrow defense of each program by different coalitions that could end up working against one another. 

This could come in the form of homeless advocates emphasizing the need for short-term rental assistance over rental-production programs, or Low-Income Housing Tax Credit advocates emphasizing that program’s “efficiency” when compared to U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development/Department of Agriculture programs, or homeownership advocates arguing that rental housing traps people in low-income communities. I have personally heard these arguments from the mouths of dedicated and well-meaning advocates and practitioners at the local, state, and federal levels.

What we need to do to build a case for all of our affordable housing efforts is . . .
New HUD User Case Studies Posted ● Click here for new case studies based on federal, state, and local strategies that increase affordable housing opportunities and support sustainable community development.
You Said It!

What a load of baloney. Paying rent is not racist. There may be racial disparities in renting versus homeownership, but that doesn’t make paying rent racist. . . . There were times in the past in the U.S. when greater housing opportunities were made available to white families, such as the . . . —Marc Brenman, more

In reply to Marc Brenman:
I would argue that your notion of racism is simplistic. It goes well beyond overt, disparate treatment (which still exists and isn’t confined to the 1930s-1950s as you imply). It includes . . . —Dan Immergluck, more

On When Deep-Income Targeting Doesn’t Hit the Mark

I’ll be circulating this article to our membership and mailing list. Our developers get it, but you articulate it very well for the broader community. —Connie Brown, Affordable Housing Consortium

How about using companies who have projects in the two divergent locations and have them subsidize the extremely low-income off the profit in the other? Something like in NYC (but it's done in the reverse / a harmful way there) where the project is granted... —Chad, more
In Case You Missed It
Executive Assistant to the President
Telesis seeks a dedicated and responsible Executive Assistant to join our Washington, D.C. office. This individual will provide administrative and support services and will have exposure to learning about community development, housing policy, and urban planning while working closely . . . Read Full Listing
Senior Developer
Telesis seeks a Senior Developer with the skills, energy, and experience to lead its work on all aspects of development, housing, and mixed-use projects. The position requires a leader who takes initiative, thinks strategically, favors a collaborative approach to problem solving, and has a sense of humor . . . Read Full Listing
Senior Housing Developer
The person in this role is engaged in activities which lead to the successful completion of affordable housing development contracts and projects, improve client capacity, and meet local community development objectives. The Senior Housing Developer plans, coordinates and manages, leading project teams, supervising . . . Read Full Listing
Housing Developer
The person in this role completes real estate development functions, including taking the lead on affordable housing and community facilities developments. The position requires experience in many aspects of housing development, as well as capacity for good time management, and to be self-motivated and use independent . . . Read Full Listing
More Jobs
Help support the voice of community development!
Featured Bloggers
Bob Annibale, Citi ● Laura Barrett, Interfaith Worker Justice ● Murtaza Baxamusa, Sol Price School of Public Policy, USC ● Michael Bodaken, National Housing Trust ● Bill Bynum, HOPE Credit Union ● Steve Dubb, Democracy Collaborative ● Jamaal Green, Portland State University ● John Henneberger, Texas Low Income Housing Information Service ● David Holtzman, newspaper reporter and former planner ● Josh Ishimatsu, National CAPACD ● Rick Jacobus, Street Level Advisors ● Daniel Kravetz, freelance writer ● Alan Mallach, Center for Community Progress ● Jonathan Reckford, Habitat for Humanity ● Doug Ryan, Prosperity Now ● Josh Silver, NCRC ● James Tracy, San Francisco Community Land Trust ● Eva Wingren, Baltimore Community Foundation